Re: ? Comyn wife out of Malise
About the Comyn daughter who was spouse regarding Malise away from Strathearn, I had theorized inside the 2005 you to she was Margaret, identified as wife out of Sir John de- Keith (see content away from article less than) who was 2ndly age are provided for the reason that blog post: brand new spouse Emma I would recommend was of another relatives, rather than mommy of your next Earl Malise.
Scots Peerage, sub _Comyn, Earl of Buchan_ , claims to some extent, ‘Malise, Earl out-of Strathearn, had a partner Emma, within the 1261-1267, whose surname is actually unknown ‘[SP II:256, cites Cal. away from Docs., i. 2383, 2451]. some time just before 1270, to ensure their widow (Margaret) would have been “available” a bit immediately after Emma.
This is definitely a speculation; it does have the advantageous asset of handling a well-known relationships anywhere between Muriel Keith and you can Reginald ce Cheyne. Any more associated documentation perform obviously become welcome.
This new account in the Scots Peerage towards group of Keith claims regarding Sir John de- Keith (d. california. 1270) that he is said to keeps hitched Comyn, earl off Buchan . This personality, of your own unclear (“said to was”) diversity, are now able to become corrected based on the after the dispensation, dated within Fondi into the 14 Jan 1378/9::
‘ Reg Aven 215, fifty To the bishop out of Moray. Professors in order to distribute Reginald Cheyn, donzel, and you may Murielle, damselle, d de- Keth, out of Moray and you may Aberdeen dioceses, about obstacle to help you marriage as a result of the 3rd and you may 4th levels of consanguinity. Fondi, 19 Kal. Feb., anno step one. SRO Vat. Trans., iv, zero. 46. ‘
Muriel Keith, the near future next partner from Robert Stewart, initial Duke out-of Albany (d. 1420), is actually developed to help you get married Reginald ce Cheyne, child of Sir Reginald ce Cheyne of the his wife (while the their unique basic husband), Helen out of Strathearn. If you find yourself there are distinguished holes throughout the origins regarding Muriel Keith, she and you may Reginald le Cheyne perform display an ancestry about Comyns. Although not, this is certainly also distant to require a dispensation in the event that Muriel try a good-great-high grandd Comyn, Earl out-of Buchan (d. 1233), that will function as the situation if the ‘s daughter.
dos. Reginald ce Cheyne are a great-grandson out of Marjory Comyn, daughter regarding Alexander Comyn, Earl away from Buchan (d. 1290), young man away from William Comyn in the list above. Their unique young buck are Malise, Earl from Strathearn off 1312 so you’re able to their demise during the 1328 , and father of Reginald.
california. 1270), are identical to Marjory Comyn, and you can hitched 2ndly so you can Malise, Earl of Strathearn (d. 1312). This will imply brand new parentage a€?said to keeps been’ regarding Margaret, spouse off Sir John de- Keith, is actually off that generation: she would n’t have become this new d Comyn, Earl from Buchan, but alternatively away from his child Alexander. There’s no evidence you to definitely Earl Malise and you will Marjory Comyn were married much before 1275: while the Lindsay authored,
There is certainly one to discernable foundation on what the partnership anywhere between Reginald ce Cheyne and you will Muriel Keith might have existed: in the event the Margaret Comyn, partner regarding Sir John de- Keith (d
‘ The newest spouse of this earl, in the 1275, is named Marjory, while we comprehend the attesting clause away from No. cv., in fact it is stated by Wyntoun, Book VIII. guy. vi., getting been another cousin away from John Comyn, Earl out of Buchan, who negotiated for Earl Malise the wedding settlement more than mentioned [old at the London, April twenty six, 1293 to have their child Matilda and you will Robert de- Tony, young buck away from Ralph].’
Alexander Comyn = Elizabeth de- Quincy Elizabeth out-of Buchan I __________________I________________ I III step one) Sir John = Marjory = 2) Malise de Keith I (als I Elizabeth away from Strathearn . 1270 I Margaret) We d. 1312 _____________I__ ___I__________________________ We I I We We We Sir William Bernard Malise Gilbert Robert Maud de Keith de Keith E regarding = Robert d. bef 1293 Strathearn; d. 1328 de Tony We ______I_______________________ We I We I Sir Edward Malise Mary Helen = Isabella de Elizabeth off Strathearn = 1) Sir Reginald Synton d. california. 1343 We le Cheyne We I I = 2) Sir David We V We We de Graham Sir William de I We__________ Keith We We = Margaret Fraser __________________I_______ V __I_____________ I We We III We We We We Muriel + Reginald Mary Mariota Keith le Cheyne (= Robert Stewart, Duke out-of Albany)